Dean Cain

Pastor Keith Atkins

Breckelle Miller

Charlotte Drake (child)

James Dickey

Eugene

Cameron Ring

Detective Emory Webster

Sarah Turner Holland

Anita Atkins

Brayden Lacer

Caleb Drake (teenager)

Eileen Lacer

Charlotte Drake (adult)

Bobby Lacer

Dexter Drake (John Doe)

Sandra Gabhart

Gigi

Ryan McElhaney

Thomas

Michael Bucci

Frank Masseria

Nick Harmon

Vincent

Shane Yuhas

Angelo

Terry Gabhart

Coroner

Rae Hunt

Principal Wallace