Martin Landau

Robert

Ellen Burstyn

Mary

Adam Scott

Mike

Elizabeth Banks

Alex

Har Mar Superstar

Peter (as Sean Tillmann)

Kali Cook

Cute Girl

Chris Wiig

Co-Worker #1 (as Christopher Why)

M. Michele Phillips

Co-Worker #2

Tina Dixon

Post Woman (as Christine Dixon)

Mary Husar

Co-Worker #3

Scott Beehner

Co-Worker #4

Todd Fink

Fancy Waiter

Ross Brockley

Grumpy Carriage Driver

Alex Curbeam

Damien Montgonmery

Michael Leach Jr.

Sled Kid #2